Mississippi Books and Writers

September 2000

Note: Prices listed below reflect the publisher's suggested list price. They are subject to change without notice.

Comrades: Brothers, Fathers, Heroes, Sons, Pals Comrades: Brothers, Fathers, Heroes, Sons, Pals

Nonfiction by Stephen E. Ambrose

Touchstone Books (Paperback, $11.00, ISBN: 0743200748)

Publication date: September 2000

Description from Kirkus Reviews:

A disappointingly sentimental celebration of male friendship that reveals almost nothing about the emotional lives of men. Bestselling historian Ambrose (Undaunted Courage, 1996, etc.) is a brilliant chronicler of public events, but his exploration of male friendship is exasperatingly shallow. How do young men become friends, according to Ambrose? They might “join the same fraternity, date the same or similar girls from the same sorority, play on the same [sports] teams, all things that lead to genuine connection.” As a University of Wisconsin freshman, Ambrose befriends a fraternity brother because “[w]e liked beer, we liked to sing when drunk, we liked girls” and enjoyed the outdoors. This hardly exhausts the infinite variety of male friendship. Ambrose portrays men as “comrades” in the public arena of sports, politics, and combat, but says little about the private roles men typically playas nurturing fathers, perhaps, or supportive husbands. In Ambrose’s estimation, men bond by sharing a goal. The friendships Ambrose has chosen to celebrate are largely forged in wartime: soldiers hitting the beaches on D-Day, George Armstrong Custer and his brother Tom dying together at Little Big Horn, Crazy Horse and his warrior friend He Dog slaughtering Custer’s men, Dwight Eisenhower and George Patton working side by side to destroy the Nazi war machine. Ambrose recycles a lot of material from his previous books and throws in a few anecdotes about his own lifelong friendships. None of it plunges much below surface platitudes. We learn, for example, that Patton and Eisenhower “both had a deep interest in tanks and armored warfare.” But where are the men who simply enjoy each others company? A vaguely nostalgic and disorganized exploration meant, no doubt, as a Father’s Day gift book. Not Ambrose’s finest hour. —Copyright 1999, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.

Beach Walks II

By George Thatcher

Quail Ridge Press (Hardcover, $9.95, ISBN: 189306221X)

Publication date: September 2000

Description: from the publisher:

Mississippi Writers Page Links
About This Site |
New Book Info | News & Events | Literary Landmarks | Mississippi Literary History | Mississippi Publishing | Other Features | Other Web Resources

by author | by title | by place | by year | by genre


Ole Miss Links
UM Home Page | English Department | Center for the Study of Southern Culture | The University of Mississippi Foundation

This page has been accessed 1703 times. About this page counter.

Last Revised on Monday, November 9, 2015, at 04:34:24 PM CST .
Send comments to

Web Design by John B. Padgett.
Copyright © 2015 The University of Mississippi English Department.